Damnation said she asked for replacement so "1)" certainly isn't the case .
Hadn't really thought about the ramifications there, so you're right. I changed my vote.
Why do you think she would do what she did as mafia? Can you offer some explanation.
Her lynch won't tell us anything. The case is she still might get replaced and if she is town her replacement will give a damn about town. (or (s)he should at least)
Whoa man, I think if you go back and look, I've mentioned my reasons like five times, at least!
I've been pushing hard for her for a looooong time now, been trying to get others to do likewise.
Her request to be lynched, and her saying that she would put the hammer down on herself was just flat out weird. It was by far the strangest thing that has occurred thus far. I believe she's mentioned something about how she wasn't going to be active anyway (which turned out to be true), but really from a town perspective, why would she do that?
After all, if she was town, wouldn't she prefer to be replaced rather than for town to make a bad lynch?
In my opinion, it looked like a scum trick:
Here's the chronology:
1) Damuna claims town/says she should be lynched
2) Town goes, "Hell no we're not going to lynch a townie. That's crazy."
3) Thereafter, it is merely assumed that Damuna is town!
The perplexing thing to me was how easily everyone accepted it. It was like a sleight-of-hand trick - you're looking at the wrong hand (the suicide suggestion) so you just assume Damuna is town.
Still with her being replaced, it does change things. In the beginning my argument was: she's either mafia or really bad town, and that's the best we can probably do one day 1, so let's get her.
Now she still might be mafia, but if she's town and she's replaced, she won't necessarily be a "bad" townie.
Factoring that in plus the fact that my arguments to lynch her over the past 2 weeks haven't won enough people over, I'm trying a different tactic now.
It's apparent we won't get Damuna so I think my backup JefeQueso is a good choice too. He's been posting and yet it almost feels like he hasn't. I feel like he's been flying under the radar. I want to see what happens now.