You two have 24 hours to reply to this thread before I attempt to find replacements.
(Yes, I am being lenient on xzyem due to him being new)

details details

I'm still on the Damuna bandwagon for now.

After reading Mafia Wiki, it is generally considered proper to notify players if there's a jester in the game. I'm sure that doesn't always hold true, but it's the best thing I have to go by.

Going under the assumption that there is no jester, then, I still find Damuna's town-claim followed by death-wish to be very suspicious, as it just the thing to throw us off the trail.

My vote will remain there until (and unless) something better comes along.

It isn't usual here. There were I think 2 jesters before (or just 1?) and players were not notified in advance. I too don't think she is jester. Jester is often discussed when people can't figure out someone's actions and in my opinion it is used as saf push for person's lynch.

Another thing, it seems Damuna basically stopped posting around the time I called his (her?) bluff on this, so I'm wondering if that wasn't just to hope the issue goes away by not replying. I recognize that at this time, virtually everything is used as "evidence" of scum behavior, whether it's being overly defensive, dismissive or in this case, ignoring it. However, really, what else is there to work with here? On the other hand, maybe he (she?) is just too busy for the game and that is the reason for requesting the lynch...

The only thing we can say, with certainty, is that expressing a death wish is the weirdest thing that any player has done so far. So when in doubt, I'm picking the weirdo. No offense, Damuna.. lol

If anyone has a better suggestion (besides the whole Nmillar/Vitek fingerpointing), then I'm all ears.

Like I said, I don't remember much about the game, apart from the fact that I was given knowledge about other players right at the start of the game, so I would have been looking for clues that matched the player names rather than looking for targets.

This is why meta-gaming is flawed - different roles generally means different play styles.

It was SirPrimalform I unvoted.
Not the end of the world, but....

He's clearly jealous of all the attention I'm giving you, and is fantasising about being you. ;)

Yeah, I need to learn to read, or perhaps not post under medication...
... Perhaps I'll leave it here for the night.

;-}

And, just as an aside, the way I see it is this:

If one mafia, chance the other is mafia slightly increases:

Rodzaju
Vitek

If one mafia, chance the other is mafia slightly increases:

Nmillar
SirPrimalForm

For Rod, Vitek it is the votes in succession. Though again, I don't really consider that suspicious under the circumstances because they were the first 2 votes when 9 votes were required to lynch.

For Nmillar and SirPrimalForm, it is the fact that Nmillar rushed to SPF's defense with a, in his words, weak/non-existent case.

However, I'm still neutral on all 4 of you. Just a thought about the possible relationships here.

I did?

Wasn't SPF the one that Rod and Vitek voted for one after another?

Oh right, I see where you're going now. They actually both voted for me, before both unvoting and voting for SirPrimalform and now have both once again unvoted and voted for me again!

Whoa... I didn't even notice that. I'll have to go back and look to verify, that's.. uh.... strange to say the least.