(So it turns out analysing your own lynch wagon is tricky. xD I'm referring to the previous NFY as NameCop to make this easier.)
So, top of my list right now is TwilightBard, for a couple of things:
First for spin-doctoring during the NFY wagon. In particular I'm thinking of the following:
(...) The problem is, if your case didn't start with Damuna, then you've let that overtake everything else. It's the clearest piece of evidence that you've pushed forward so far. (...)
(...)Even NFY when brought to L-1 and unvoted only to avoid a speedlynch tried to throw punches without regard of how it looks. I think she just got lucky that someone pointed out GoJays.(...) NotFrenchYet:
Both of those posts I quoted seem to use ammunition gleaned from skim-reading the thread. The Damuna Issue was discussed an awful lot, but NameCop repeatedly stated she agreed with the criticism of it. As for the second one, NameCop had already stated she wanted to articulate suspicions and had even rebuked Robbeasy for the same spin. And even a cursory re-reading would have revealed that NameCop was the first to vote for GoJays. The errors are a little convenient for my liking.
And I'm afraid my soul is still sore about what happened to its previous body, where TB and The Baron seemed to have ignored #1276... TB even claimed that NameCop hadn't put up much in the way of defence. :< Vote TwilightBard
Here's a problem I have with 1276...it's not a defense. It's a summary using post numbers. What you did with post 1017 is more along the lines of what I was looking for when I mean a defense. It makes it frustrating though with 1017 being over a month ago is that I honestly can't tell you where my mind was at, or what I was thinking.
As for 1387...All I can say is yes, I've been scanning posts at that point because no one was willing at that point to bring up anything of real value, and everyone was talking mainly for the sake of having posts then having anything meaningful to say. I was begging for someone to try to make a case or show something other then what I was capable of seeing (I can't see or catch everything), and I was honestly seeing people go 'Well, I'm going with my gut and I don't have a gut feeling strong enough.' I pointed out that I voted Namecop more because of the case there (And I was sadly hoping that someone would be able to deconstruct the damn thing in a useful way) then for my actual gut feeling because at this point, I don't trust my gut feelings anymore in this game. I've been burned way too many times by this.
While I can't say I know for certain on both groups, I do have a question to propose. Why does everyone think that GoJays was left alive? I don't mean this as an attack on GoJays, but I'm very curious as to what everyone thinks of this (I believe that he's town actually), but a living roleblocker is an amazing mistake that someone didn't pick up on...and I don't think it could be from one of our experienced players either. It doesn't make sense to me, and I believe GoJays is telling the truth.