Why do you see R_B leaning scum, Krypsyn?
I was thinking mainly of his post 968
where he just writes, basically, "I think stoic is guilty and NFY is innocent, but I'll get back to you with reasons.", but then seems to drop it. This is a common scummy tactic; not backing up accusations. I guess I did this with RB too in the last post, but I an rectifying that now, I hope. ;)
However, while searching for that post, I ran across his post 1065
in which he does support his accusations somewhat. I think his reasons are a little confusing (3 mafias, etc), but at lest he made a case. I still consider him 'leaning scum' however, for his weak-seeming support of NFY and his confusing post backing it up 100 posts later.
It is interesting to note, though, that he throws attention on TwilightBard in the the second post. It is interesting to me, mainly, because I pointed a finger at TB a few posts ago. I don't think they can both be scum. It is possible that they are both scum and not on the same scum-team, though. Regardless, TB is leaning slightly more town to me after noticing that.
NotFrenchYet - I don't know what to say on her at this point. Leaning scum on her for all the reasons I've put forth earlier. That said, I can't ignore the fact that she's been active in a game where I tend to think mafia would prefer NOT to be active. So that generally looks town. I guess the weird thing for me at this point is that when I was actively prosecuting her, no one was on my side. Now that I've backed off, a number of people have begun to believe she is scum.
I wasn't in the game, but I was totally wishing I could vote NFY along with you. I am not the only one, either, judging my gameon's brief time in the game. He voted NFY, and gave a FOS to jefequeso (IIRC), almost immediately. I think it is because both of us probably read the game in a much shorter time-frame. I know I read the first 800 or so posts in a few days of off-and-on reading. Certain things like circular arguments or bringing up the same weak arguments over and over really stand out more if you see them again and again in the same sitting.
Now that the deadline has been lifted, if my theory is correct, we should expect to see an uptick in mafia posts. So I'm curious to go back and see if a few people have become active all of the sudden (excluding the replacements of course).
Exactly, and this is part of the reason I am trying to get EVERYONE to post their feelings. I am sure they are going to be posting, but I don't want to see meaningless fluff posts. If they post, I want to see some meat there (even if it is scummy fake tofu-meat).