Sharim - can't remember much. picky about Zchnique's oddities. could be mafia. This is a question that got thrown around in game 6 - Why SHOULD you be lynched?
Baron - difficult to read. could be town. Care to take a meaningless/completely contrived guess at who the first nightkill might be?
I find these two questions odd. Care to enlighten me on the thought process behind them?
What's with the recent sudden switch to Nmillar, without any explanation? And I still read your mid-20s posts as being quite scummy.
Switch? That indicates going from something to something else. This was no switch, my good man.
Also, humour me, what did you find scummy about the posts you mention?
Lot of players is scummy right now but if I had to pick one it would be...itai.sharim I guess.
That said: Unvote Stuart, vote nmillar
I support Zchinque.
Ah, thank you, now I can answer about why I inquired about nmillar's thoughts on you. It was not so much his answers I was interested in, as your reaction. At that point, you had posted quite a bit, relatively speaking, but all your posts lacked one thing - any content relating to the game. Frequent posting of non-content can often be a sign of scum active-lurking or trying to slip under the radar, so I considered it a viable lead to advance on, although in a somewhat roundabout way.
And to answer your question from #114, I have no reason whatsoever to trust nmillar's opinion more than any other player in the game.
I'll let it roll a bit to see where Zchinque takes us because I do think he is town.
Almost all of Z's posts from the 20-30 range seem anti-town, or at least suspicious. He claims that he's identified at least 2 scum in the first 15 posts, then threaten Joe (post 17).
'Twas a reference to Vitek and Joe sharing inside information to who this "Liam" fellow might be. Typically, two people sharing inside information in a game of mafia - in particular on day 1 - is indication of them being mafia. Hence voting for Vitek and telling Joe he was going down tomorrow. Of course, it was a random vote, and all in jest.
That combined with post 25 seems like almost a power role claim.
How do you get a power claim from that?
It's then revealed in posts 44 and 45 that, in a previous game, he spent his time throwing the entire town into confusion, which seems to me to be one of the most anti-town things you could do.
Which has what bearing on this game, exactly?
So I don't trust him. Either he's scum, or he's a townie who is effectively anti-town. Does this mean that I'm going to push for a lynch? No. There's not enough evidence yet. But at this point, I think he's the most suspicious person.
If I am either scum or an anti-town townie - which seems a strange dichotomy, but let's roll with it - why
are you not pushing for my lynch?
He has thrown out a totally random and unexplained vote and everyone is now focused on this and reacting to it.
That something is unexplained doesn't make it random.
*snipped by Zchinque*
He has thrown out a totally random and unexplained vote and everyone is now focused on this and reacting to it. I think it's a ploy and only makes me suspicious for one reason, and that is Vitek's vote.
*snipped by Zchinque*
What exactly is this ploy trying to achieve?
You'll have to ask Zchinque that.
No, asking you that seems fair. If you think it's a ploy, I'm sure you have some ideas about what you think that ploy might be, or what intended effect it might have.
Also, why does only Vitek's vote make the alleged ploy suspicious?
Is this nmillar thing something we should avoid asking about?
You may ask, but I might not answer. Indeed, you should always ask, perphaps unless you are clearly stated asked not to. Then you should ask (probably yourself) why you shouldn't ask, and if you can't find a good answer, ask anyway.
So then what do you think to the suggestion that peanutbrittle, zchnique and orryyrro are our mafia team? It's just a baseless thought on my part.
((I hope Rod and any other observers we might have would be suitably impressed if I have just managed to name the scum. Of course if I have it's not going to be much help at this stage. I'm going into too much detail, keep it simple.))
Psst - saying that it's baseless makes it less impressive if correct.
here's a question for you Zchinique - Did you expect vitek to vote with you?
Effectively you're asking whether or not I admit that myself and Vitek can communicate outside of the thread?
No, I had no reason to expect Vitek to vote for nmillar. He had given no prior indication - at least not that I've picked up - that he had any suspicion in that direction.
Zchinque - I don't like the secrecy, the weird behaviour, and the refusal to answer questions. Oddly enough, it almost makes me think he's town just because I can't imagine scum would ever try to act that suspicious. Of course, maybe that's his angle.
I thought I had posted this already.... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9s0UURBihH8
If I'm not around much in the next bit, it's holiday related.
Don't worry, as your contribution so far can be summed up to "I don't have a town read on anyone", there's not much to miss.
Please post something.
I can't help but suspect that you've gone and left us again. Forgive me for speaking for everyone but you have us awaiting your next word. What is in your mind?
Why would you be awaiting my word? I do not think you need my permission for, well, anything really.
Rodzaju: Quick question:
Is anyone expecting to be out of contact for more than 5 of the next 12 days?
Enough people have said that they will be around that Isee no need to extend the deadline.
Unless the day ends naturally beforehand, Night will fall 11pm GMT January 3.
Due to Cristmas & new year, I will not prod anyone for the remainder of the day.
I'd like to ask you to reconsider.
If you're going to keep a strict deadline over Christmas, I think you should prod accordingly. Mod-approved lurking is a very powerful tool for the mafia.
Even still I might consider and extention, as even if people post every 48 hours, which isn't necessarily that much, activity is bound to drop anywho.