I'm looking for games that have the atmosphere of the first Diablo.
So basically an ARPG or RPG-ish or even turn based with a heavy dark, creepy and gothic atmosphere.
After the second Diablo everyone went doing their games with big open areas and moved away from just the dungeon design.
Before this one gets derailed Titan Quest is out from the start because it's in the open, it's always sunny, has no blood/gore. It's just too "happy go lucky" :)
Torchlight on the other hand got the dungeon and mechanics right, but went the cartoony way without giving you purpose of what you are doing or fighting.
Only game that I can think of is Grim Dawn, but that is not yet in alpha.
Games I have played (that I can remember at this moment):
Everything Infinity engine based
Dungeons of Dredmore