I have to grab gothic 2 at some point.
Grab Gothic 2. For only 9.99 US you get more content than most of the new releases in the RPG genre. Besides that, the game aged so damn well that it looks better than Gothic 3. Hell, it just looks damn awesome even without the apocalyptic levels of bloom and all that other crap that infests games of today.
Also, it has the choice of G2 controls or Gothic 1 controls for when you are feeling hardcore and all.
One thing about all our comments here, bringing the subject back around to the topic, is that none of them are fake. All of our comments about Gothic are real: anyone that reads this and other threads can see that, I think.
Unless we are just a thousand monkeys banging on a thousand keyboards...