The 25$ price tag is just insulting. The only way I can treat both Enhanced Editions seriously is if they were 5$ addons to the original games (I still wouldn't buy them though).
If only they actually improved the graphics, they whine that the can't do it because the original art assets were lost (had they not been lost they could have just been recompiled at a higher resolution from the vector assets)...
Well, they could have recreated them from scratch, only in HD this time. That would justify a 50$ price tag too. Their reply to that was that this is beyond the scope of their overhaul... some overhaul. Ooh, iPad and DLC support, THANK YOU! /sarcasm
This is something they really really should have done a kickstarter for (that is, a kickstarter exclusively to fund artists to recreate the art assets to allow proper HDifying)
That being said, I disagree about it being all bad. Ignoring the price, now that the bugs were fixed BGEE is strictly speaking superior BG1 experience than BGTuTu, BG1, and BGT.